← Guides

GUIDE

Handling returns and withdrawals cleanly in your Shopify shop

After the first orders come the first withdrawals. That is normal and precisely regulated by law. For you as a trader, fixed deadlines on both sides count: how long the customer may withdraw, and how quickly you must refund. This article shows the process from withdrawal to refund and how you handle it with Shopify’s built-in tools.

When the right of withdrawal applies and how the period runs

Consumers have a right of withdrawal of 14 days on online purchases. That is set out in § 355 BGB. For a purchase of goods the period starts, under § 356(2) BGB, when the goods are received, not when the purchase is concluded, and then runs without interruption; without this special rule, conclusion of the contract would be decisive under § 355(2) BGB. To meet the deadline it is enough that the withdrawal declaration is sent in time; the parcel need not have arrived with you by then. An email on the last day is therefore enough. The other side matters: if you have not properly informed the customer of the right of withdrawal, under § 356 BGB it expires only at the latest twelve months and 14 days after receipt of the goods, not after the usual 14 days. Enter the receipt date of every withdrawal declaration on the order immediately. That is your only reliable basis for everything that follows.

The withdrawal: from receipt to confirmation

A withdrawal does not have to be reasoned and can be made without a particular form. A short email or the model withdrawal form from § 356 BGB, which you can offer in your withdrawal notice but do not have to, is usual. Confirm receipt of every withdrawal declaration as promptly as possible on a durable medium. In practice a short confirmation email to the customer is enough for that; a statutory confirmation duty under § 356 BGB only arises if you offer the customer your own online withdrawal form and they use it. Keep two points in time clearly separate internally: receipt of the withdrawal declaration, which starts your refund period, and the later receipt of the returned goods, which counts for your warehouse. You can record both times as a note on the order in Shopify, so that you do not have to guess when a deadline runs out.

Refunds: deadline, means of payment and return shipping costs

Under § 357 BGB you refund all payments including standard shipping costs at the latest 14 days after receipt of the withdrawal declaration, not only after you have the goods back. In a consumer goods purchase, however, you may refuse repayment until you have received the goods back or the customer presents proof of dispatch, whichever happens first. The refund must run through the same means of payment that was used for the purchase. A one-sided switch to a voucher is not permitted. The customer bears the direct costs of return shipping if you informed them of this in the withdrawal notice in advance. If that notice is missing, you bear them. If the customer chose a more expensive shipping method than your cheapest standard option, you only refund the cheaper amount. The difference stays with the customer.

Processing refunds in Shopify

In Shopify you open the order concerned and click Refund. There you choose between a full and a partial refund and adjust individual line items separately. Shipping costs are not refunded automatically. You enter the amount manually in the field for the shipping-cost refund; in a full withdrawal that is as a rule the entire shipping amount paid. In the refund dialogue choose the original means of payment as the repayment method. Shopify then transfers automatically back there, and you fulfil § 357 BGB. Briefly enter the reason for the refund. That later helps you see which products come back more often than average. Then quickly check inventory.

Creating a return in Shopify and the return label

Under the order, via Create return, you open a return process, choose the items concerned, the reason and whether you provide a return label. You can generate a return label directly in Shopify only if both your primary location and the customer’s delivery address are in the United States. For German shops this function is therefore not available. As an alternative you upload an externally purchased label as a PDF, PNG or JPEG, or you enter a tracking number and carrier, or you choose the option without shipping information if you send the label separately by email. For DHL shipping within Germany you can buy DHL Parcel and Kleinpaket labels directly from Shopify, but that only covers shipping to the customer; for the return you use, as described above, an externally obtained label to upload or the option without shipping information.

Communicating with customers

A withdrawal or returns email needs few sentences: confirmation that the declaration has arrived, what the customer has to do next, that is send the goods back or nothing further, and by when they can expect the refund. Avoid vague wording such as “shortly”. Name the 14-day period concretely instead, so that no follow-up questions arise. If a return arrives damaged or incomplete, you briefly and factually explain what is missing before you make a partial refund, instead of paying less back without comment. A short, honest reply in practice saves more time than any long template, because it usually makes the second follow-up email unnecessary.

What the Markenstart starter pack provides and what it does not

The Markenstart starter pack contains text templates as working material around withdrawal and returns, including a withdrawal-notice template and a customer-friendly shipping-and-returns page for the footer menu, which you adapt to your shop. The templates have not been legally reviewed. You take them on at your own risk and adapt deadlines, contact details and the return address yourself. What the kit does not provide: an automatic connection to Shopify, a return-label tool or a legal review of your specific situation. You still set up refunds, returns management and shipping labels in your Shopify admin; for return labels in Germany, if needed, via an externally obtained label that you upload there.

Your returns checklist

Sources

Templates instead of starting from scratch? Finished templates that have not been legally reviewed, for the withdrawal notice and shipping and returns, are in the Markenstart starter pack; you get a first overview free of charge with the checklist.

Note: This is general information, not legal advice. Check your withdrawal notice and your returns process before launch yourself, or have them legally reviewed.